Updated
Updated · ZDNet · Jul 31
Smartwings Roller Shades Win Editors' Choice as $1,200 Setup Undercuts Premium Smart Shades
Updated
Updated · ZDNet · Jul 31

Smartwings Roller Shades Win Editors' Choice as $1,200 Setup Undercuts Premium Smart Shades

2 articles · Updated · ZDNet · Jul 31

Summary

  • ZDNET gave Smartwings Roller Shades its Editors' Choice award for best value after a hands-on review found the motorized shades easy to install, quiet and reliable across smart-home platforms.
  • Four blackout shades with Zigbee motors and light blockers cost about $1,200, and the reviewer estimated outfitting a 3,000-square-foot home would stay under $10,000—well below the $15,000 to $50,000 often spent on whole-home window treatments.
  • Smartwings' appeal centered on customization and compatibility: buyers can choose sizes, finishes and motors supporting Matter over Thread, Zigbee, Z-Wave, HomeKit, Alexa, Google Home and SmartThings, with optional solar charging.
  • The main drawbacks were a plastic smell that lasted three to four days after installation and the lack of manual operation if the battery dies, leaving USB-C charging as the fallback.

Insights

With no manual backup or dedicated app, are affordable smart shades a convenience or a hidden trap?
How often do you really need to recharge these smart shades before being stuck in the dark?