Updated
Updated · Ars Technica · Aug 11
9th Circuit Clears Meta's $1.4 Trillion Addiction Trial, Rejecting Section 230 Shield
Updated
Updated · Ars Technica · Aug 11

9th Circuit Clears Meta's $1.4 Trillion Addiction Trial, Rejecting Section 230 Shield

3 articles · Updated · Ars Technica · Aug 11

Summary

  • A 3-0 Ninth Circuit panel dismissed Meta and TikTok’s appeals, clearing the way for a California-led consumer-protection trial against Meta to move ahead this month.
  • Section 230 is a defense to liability, not immunity from suit, the judges said, leaving them without jurisdiction to halt the case on an interlocutory appeal.
  • August 12 jury selection is set to begin before an August 19 trial, and the court also denied Meta’s emergency bid to stay proceedings as moot.
  • More than $1.4 trillion in damages is at stake, according to Meta’s July filing, in claims by California, Colorado, Kentucky and New Jersey that Meta deceived the public about addiction harms.
  • The ruling also reinforces a broader appellate decision letting thousands of youth social-media addiction lawsuits against major platforms continue.

Insights

Will massive jury payouts force tech giants to redesign their algorithms, or just become a new cost of doing business?
If social media features are legally treated like defective products, could this destroy the internet's engagement-driven business model?