1965 Pumpkin Butterprint Pyrex Fetches Hundreds on Resale Market
Updated
Updated · Chowhound · Aug 16
1965 Pumpkin Butterprint Pyrex Fetches Hundreds on Resale Market
3 articles · Updated · Chowhound · Aug 16
Summary
1965 Pumpkin Butterprint Pyrex pieces are drawing asking prices in the hundreds of dollars on resale sites, making the pattern a prized thrift-store find.
Limited production drove that demand: the line was issued as a promotional set of four, leaving relatively few examples in circulation.
Most resale pieces show orange-on-white harvest scenes—sometimes labeled Amish Butterprint—while turquoise versions were also made.
Authentication is narrower than for many vintage wares because Pumpkin Butterprint appears to have been produced only in Pyrex's Cinderella bowl form, with nesting bowls featuring handle-like pouring lips.
That shape, discontinued in the early 1980s, helps collectors distinguish genuine vintage pieces and explains why even a single bowl can carry value.