Updated
Updated · CNN · Aug 17
Supreme Court Finalizes Trump’s $5.6 Million Carroll Payment as Rehearing Bid Fails
Updated
Updated · CNN · Aug 17

Supreme Court Finalizes Trump’s $5.6 Million Carroll Payment as Rehearing Bid Fails

3 articles · Updated · CNN · Aug 17

Summary

  • $5.6 million owed by Donald Trump to E. Jean Carroll is now effectively locked in after the Supreme Court refused to reconsider its June rejection of his appeal.
  • The ruling ends Trump’s path in Carroll’s 2022 civil case, where a jury found he sexually abused and defamed her and awarded $5 million, later rising with interest.
  • No justice publicly dissented, and Trump had already paid the money under a lower-court order while Carroll’s lawyers said it would remain in an interest-bearing account until rehearing was denied.
  • Trump had argued the trial was tainted by testimony from two other women and the 2005 Access Hollywood tape, but the 2nd Circuit previously found no errors warranting a new trial.
  • A separate Carroll judgment of about $83 million from her 2019 defamation case is still pending at the Supreme Court.

Insights

Now that the Supreme Court has closed the door, what happens to the nearly $5.8 million currently sitting in legal limbo?
Could the admission of highly contested evidence in this finalized trial reshape how future high-profile defamation cases are fought?