Updated
Updated · The New York Times · Aug 27
Kansas Judge Dismisses Deputy's 2nd-Degree Murder Charge in 2025 Jail Death
Updated
Updated · The New York Times · Aug 27

Kansas Judge Dismisses Deputy's 2nd-Degree Murder Charge in 2025 Jail Death

3 articles · Updated · The New York Times · Aug 27

Summary

  • Wyandotte County Judge Aaron Roberts dismissed the second-degree murder case against Deputy Richard Fatherley, ruling prosecutors had not met the burden to move the case from a preliminary hearing to trial.
  • Prosecutors immediately filed a notice of appeal after the Thursday decision, saying they disagreed with dropping all charges.
  • Fatherley had been accused in the July 2025 death of Charles Adair, a handcuffed inmate who was later found unresponsive after the deputy allegedly knelt on his lower back in a jail cell.
  • Adair, arrested on misdemeanor traffic-warrant charges and using a wheelchair, was later pronounced dead; an autopsy classified the death as a homicide.
  • The case drew regional outcry in Kansas City last year, and Adair's death remains the subject of an unresolved federal lawsuit.

Insights

How could a judge dismiss a murder case when an autopsy revealed the inmate died from mechanical asphyxia and broken ribs?
Will the unresolved federal lawsuit finally uncover the truth about the fatal 2025 jailhouse restraint that local courts just dismissed?