Updated
Updated · O'Reilly Media · Sep 3
Anthropic Settlement to Pay Andrew Stellman About $9,000 Over Pirated Books Used in Claude Training
Updated
Updated · O'Reilly Media · Sep 3

Anthropic Settlement to Pay Andrew Stellman About $9,000 Over Pirated Books Used in Claude Training

1 articles · Updated · O'Reilly Media · Sep 3

Summary

  • About $9,000 is due to Andrew Stellman, a similar amount to coauthor Jenny Greene and roughly $18,000 to O’Reilly under a settlement approved in July over pirated book copies used to train Claude.
  • The payout works out to a little more than $3,000 per book edition, with each edition counted separately, though Stellman said checks may still take months because of the administrative process.
  • Stellman argues the money matters less than attribution: he wants AI systems to identify when answers draw on his books and point users back to the original work.
  • He says current chatbot citations usually reflect live retrieval, not training data, but points to methods such as TracIn and influence functions — and a 37,000-parameter demo he built — as evidence attribution is technically possible.
  • The bigger obstacle, he argues, is legal risk: if labs explicitly credit a source, that acknowledgment could bolster willful-infringement claims carrying up to $150,000 per work.

Insights

If giving creators credit exposes AI companies to massive lawsuits, will the legal system permanently destroy the concept of attribution?
With a historic billion-dollar settlement finally approved, why are the winning authors insisting the money is the least important part?
Can emerging techniques finally force black-box AI models to reveal exactly which human creators they secretly learned their answers from?