Updated
Updated · Fox News · Sep 4
DHS Counsel Percival Seeks Florida Bar Probe of 128 Former Judges After Complaint Rejected
Updated
Updated · Fox News · Sep 4

DHS Counsel Percival Seeks Florida Bar Probe of 128 Former Judges After Complaint Rejected

1 articles · Updated · Fox News · Sep 4

Summary

  • 128 former judges who accused James Percival of unethical attacks on sitting judges are now the target of his request that the Florida Bar scrutinize signers who are Bar members.
  • The countermove followed the Bar's refusal to investigate Percival, saying it does not prosecute sitting officers appointed under the U.S. Constitution while they remain in office.
  • Percival said the judges should have known that policy before filing and argued their 24-page complaint was a frivolous, politically motivated abuse of the disciplinary process he called "Bar-fare."
  • The original complaint, led by former Florida Supreme Court Chief Justice Peggy Quince and backed by rule-of-law groups, said Percival's "Worst of the Worst Judges" posts mischaracterized rulings and could erode confidence in courts.
  • The dispute centers on Percival's public attacks on judges in cases involving Temporary Protected Status, Kilmar Abrego Garcia and DHS use-of-force policy, widening a broader fight over criticism of the judiciary.

Insights

Where is the exact line between protected legal advocacy and dangerous rhetoric that puts judges at physical risk?
How does a state bar's jurisdictional limit create an ethics accountability loophole for sitting federal officials?