Updated
Updated · Constitutional Accountability Center · Sep 9
CAC Files Supreme Court Brief in Genalo v. Black After 14 Months of Immigration Detention
Updated
Updated · Constitutional Accountability Center · Sep 9

CAC Files Supreme Court Brief in Genalo v. Black After 14 Months of Immigration Detention

1 articles · Updated · Constitutional Accountability Center · Sep 9

Summary

  • September 8 brought a new Supreme Court amicus brief from the Constitutional Accountability Center backing a detainee held more than 14 months without a bond hearing under 8 U.S.C. § 1226(c).
  • CAC argues the Fifth Amendment protects noncitizens as “persons” and bars prolonged immigration detention without a neutral hearing to test flight risk or danger.
  • The filing asks the justices to uphold a May 2024 Second Circuit ruling that called the detainee’s confinement “unreasonably prolonged” and unconstitutional without bond review.
  • The government lost its bid for en banc rehearing in the Second Circuit before winning Supreme Court review, setting up a broader test of how far mandatory detention can extend during deportation cases.

Insights

With the Supreme Court case abruptly mooted, how long can noncitizens legally face mandatory detention without a bond hearing?
If the Fifth Amendment protects all persons, why does prolonged mandatory immigration detention still evade a definitive constitutional ruling?
Could historical bail practices from the 19th century ultimately dismantle modern mandatory immigration detention laws?