Updated
Updated · Defector · Sep 16
Mets Fans Chant 'Fire Stearns' After Alonso's 300th Homer in 11-Inning Loss
Updated
Updated · Defector · Sep 16

Mets Fans Chant 'Fire Stearns' After Alonso's 300th Homer in 11-Inning Loss

3 articles · Updated · Defector · Sep 16

Summary

  • Tuesday’s return game for Pete Alonso turned into a protest as Mets fans again chanted “Fire Stearns” after the former slugger tied the game with his 300th career home run.
  • The backlash came a day after New York’s playoff elimination and reflected anger over a $340 million roster that missed the postseason, with Alonso’s departure becoming a symbol of the club’s failed season.
  • David Stearns, who has run baseball operations since 2024, drew blame from fans who link him to Alonso not being re-signed and to the Mets’ league-worst first-base production after Jorge Polanco played only 37 games.
  • Sean Manaea said cheering an opposing player that way was “crazy” and “different,” while Kodai Senga, who allowed the homer, said the reaction showed how much Alonso was loved.
  • The scene has already fueled a split among Mets fans online, underscoring how a disappointing season is ending in recrimination despite a wave of promising young players.

Insights

Why did a New York crowd give an opposing player a curtain call while their own $350 million team collapsed?
What hidden roster risks caused a massive $350 million baseball empire to crumble so spectacularly in 2026?