Updated
Updated · Science News Magazine · Oct 14
DeepMind Details AI System That Solved 9 Erdős Problems, as Math Community Debates Openness
Updated
Updated · Science News Magazine · Oct 14

DeepMind Details AI System That Solved 9 Erdős Problems, as Math Community Debates Openness

2 articles · Updated · Science News Magazine · Oct 14

Summary

  • A peer-reviewed Science paper made public this week shows Google DeepMind’s AlphaProof Nexus solved 9 of 353 open Erdős problems, with human mathematicians vetting many of the proofs.
  • The study says the system used multiple Gemini-powered agents, Lean proof-checking software and, for harder steps, the AlphaProof math model to generate and test proof attempts.
  • A simpler setup without shared agents or AlphaProof still solved the same 9 problems, suggesting stronger language models plus formal checking tools can handle some research math at lower cost.
  • Lean verification still has limits because mathematical statements can be mistranslated into code; an October 6 preprint flagged mismatches between parts of OpenAI’s written Navier-Stokes proof and its Lean version.
  • The publication lands amid a backlash over AI-generated math deluges: one Erdős-problem tracker shut comments and open/solved tags, while critics warn competitive releases are eroding collaboration and trust.

Insights

If Lean verifies the code but not the meaning, who decides whether an AI proof actually solves the math problem it claims to?
After 722 AI-generated math papers, can mathematicians keep research open without drowning in opaque proofs and possible reuse of unpublished ideas?