Updated
Updated · Fox News · Nov 2
Big 12 Admits BYU TD Was Wrong, Says Arizona State Should Have Faced 3rd-and-goal at 2
Updated
Updated · Fox News · Nov 2

Big 12 Admits BYU TD Was Wrong, Says Arizona State Should Have Faced 3rd-and-goal at 2

3 articles · Updated · Fox News · Nov 2

Summary

  • The Big 12 said replay officials wrongly awarded BYU a touchdown in its Halloween game against Arizona State after a whistle had already blown on Bear Bachmeier’s goal-line fumble.
  • Conference officials said the correct ruling was BYU ball on third-and-goal from the 2-yard line, because Sione Moa could recover the fumble but could not advance it for a score after the play was ruled dead.
  • Arizona State coach Kenny Dillingham argued during and after the game that the ball should not have been advanced, directing frustration at the replay decision rather than the on-field crew.
  • The admission adds to a string of recent BYU officiating controversies, including the Big 12 acknowledging 1 second remained after Notre Dame’s final incompletion and criticism of a late clock ruling in BYU’s loss at UCF.
  • The error lands ahead of No. 7 BYU’s rivalry game at No. 3 Utah, with Utah 5-0 and both BYU and Texas Tech 4-1 in a tight Big 12 race.

Insights

Will the Big 12's string of admitted replay center errors ultimately taint BYU's legitimate push for a College Football Playoff spot?
With replay centers taking the blame for game-altering mistakes, what hidden systemic flaws are compromising the integrity of college football?