Updated
Updated · The Guardian · Nov 4
Ed Kelsey Links Winterson's AI View to Asimov's 1959 Story "Profession"
Updated
Updated · The Guardian · Nov 4

Ed Kelsey Links Winterson's AI View to Asimov's 1959 Story "Profession"

1 articles · Updated · The Guardian · Nov 4

Summary

  • Ed Kelsey said Jeanette Winterson’s call for “well-rounded people” in an AI-driven future closely mirrors Isaac Asimov’s 1959 story "Profession".
  • Kelsey, a former 13-year-old Asimov fan who later became a computer programmer, said the tale depicts highly automated societies that still depend on some broadly educated specialists.
  • His letter responds to Winterson’s Oct. 28 interview, which argued there is “no inevitable dystopia” in AI and that society will still need doctors, chemists and generalists.
  • A second reader, Arthur Gould, extended that optimism, arguing a superior AI could help avert climate catastrophe, restrain war and block nuclear destruction.

Insights

Could the well-rounded generalist praised by sci-fi simply be a temporary fix before autonomous AI fully replaces human workflow management?
Will delegating global crises to AI actually save humanity, or just surrender our future to the hidden prejudices of corporate algorithms?
If AI is rapidly seniorising entry-level jobs, how will the next generation of workers ever gain the experience needed to survive?