Updated
Updated · The New York Times · Nov 16
Judge May Set 2nd Lindsay Clancy Trial Date as 11-1 Jury Deadlock Leaves Charges Unclear
Updated
Updated · The New York Times · Nov 16

Judge May Set 2nd Lindsay Clancy Trial Date as 11-1 Jury Deadlock Leaves Charges Unclear

3 articles · Updated · The New York Times · Nov 16

Summary

  • Monday’s 10 a.m. hearing in Plymouth Superior Court could produce a tentative start date for Lindsay Clancy’s retrial after her first case ended in a mistrial.
  • Nearly 40 hours of deliberations failed to break an 11-1 split in September, and prosecutors still have not said whether they will retry first-degree murder, reduce the charges, or drop a second trial.
  • Last week Judge William Sullivan rejected defense motions to dismiss the case and to further investigate the lone holdout juror, ruling deeper questioning would have been impermissibly coercive.
  • A reduced charge such as second-degree murder or manslaughter could let Clancy, 36, waive a new jury trial and have a judge decide the case instead.
  • The six-week televised trial over the deaths of Clancy’s 3 children reignited debate over postpartum mental illness and may complicate seating an impartial new jury.

Insights

Will prosecutors reduce the murder charges against Lindsay Clancy to bypass a jury and let a judge decide her fate?
How can an impartial jury be found for a mother whose tragic postpartum psychosis case has already divided the nation?
Could the lone holdout juror's alleged secret permanently derail the prosecution's quest for a second murder trial?