Thomas Warns Supreme Court Lets California Compel Speech in 50-Hour Doctor Training Case
Updated
Updated · Fox News · Nov 16
Thomas Warns Supreme Court Lets California Compel Speech in 50-Hour Doctor Training Case
3 articles · Updated · Fox News · Nov 16
Summary
Three justices dissented after the Supreme Court refused to hear a California physician’s challenge to a rule requiring implicit-bias instruction in doctors’ continuing education.
Thomas, joined by Samuel Alito, said the denial leaves room for states to force private speakers to deliver a government-favored message, arguing the First Amendment still applies when officials script private speech.
California requires licensed physicians to complete 50 hours of state-approved education every two years, and those courses must address implicit bias through examples or strategies tied to healthcare disparities.
The Ninth Circuit had ruled the courses amount to government speech because California heavily regulates medicine; the state also argued instructors may openly disagree while still covering the topic.
The court’s refusal leaves that ruling in place without resolving the broader constitutional question Thomas said could spill into other licensed professions beyond medicine.