Updated
Updated · Fox News · Nov 17
Alabama Judge David Carpenter Denounces 2022 Aniah's Law as Assault on Bail Rights
Updated
Updated · Fox News · Nov 17

Alabama Judge David Carpenter Denounces 2022 Aniah's Law as Assault on Bail Rights

2 articles · Updated · Fox News · Nov 17

Summary

  • David Carpenter, a Jefferson County circuit judge under scrutiny for past release decisions, called Alabama’s Aniah’s Law a direct assault on the presumption of innocence and opposed holding defendants without bail based only on charges.
  • His criticism followed this year’s voter-approved expansion of the 2022 constitutional amendment, which added attempted murder, murder conspiracy and firing into occupied buildings or vehicles to offenses eligible for bail denial.
  • Carpenter argued on Facebook that Americans worry more about surveillance tools such as Flock license-plate cameras than about laws that let the government jail people indefinitely before trial.
  • The remarks land amid backlash over Carpenter’s earlier rulings, including a 2023 plea deal for Damien McDaniel, later linked by Birmingham police to more than a dozen killings, and bond or sentencing decisions in other violent cases.
  • The dispute highlights Alabama’s broader clash between tougher pretrial detention for violent crime and criminal-justice reform arguments centered on constitutional protections and prison overcrowding.

Insights

With Alabama prisons facing severe DOJ scrutiny, will expanding pretrial detention protect the public or collapse an already broken system?
Can a judge's fight for the presumption of innocence survive when his past rulings are linked to a trail of fatal shootings?