Updated
Updated · The New York Times · Nov 17
Alito Warns Court Overhaul Could Permanently Change Supreme Court as Democrats Eye January Push
Updated
Updated · The New York Times · Nov 17

Alito Warns Court Overhaul Could Permanently Change Supreme Court as Democrats Eye January Push

3 articles · Updated · The New York Times · Nov 17

Summary

  • Justice Samuel Alito said proposals to alter the Supreme Court’s composition could fundamentally and perhaps permanently change the institution, warning that judicial independence depends on freedom from political pressure.
  • Speaking at an American Enterprise Institute dinner, Alito said critics have tried to intimidate justices, damage the court’s public standing and then justify structural changes if rulings do not go their way.
  • January control of Congress by Democrats gives new relevance to that warning, with reform ideas including court expansion, term limits and tighter ethics rules after a series of conservative-majority decisions.
  • Recent polling has shown the court’s standing slipping, with a September Marquette survey finding a majority of Americans believe justices are driven mainly by politics rather than law.
  • Alito, who wrote the 2022 decision overturning Roe v. Wade, also signaled he plans to stay on the bench at least through next summer despite speculation he might retire before Democrats take the Senate.

Insights

Will the increasing reliance on emergency dockets eventually trigger unprecedented structural transformations within the judicial system?