The Last Critic Premieres at Doc NYC, Framing Robert Christgau’s 60-Year Music-Criticism Career
Updated
Updated · The Guardian · Nov 17
The Last Critic Premieres at Doc NYC, Framing Robert Christgau’s 60-Year Music-Criticism Career
2 articles · Updated · The Guardian · Nov 17
Summary
Doc NYC is screening The Last Critic, a new documentary on 84-year-old Robert Christgau that portrays him still writing and listening obsessively from his East Village apartment.
Director Matty Wishnow centers the film on Christgau’s nearly 60-year Consumer Guide project, the capsule-review franchise that made the self-styled “Dean of American Rock Critics” a defining voice from the Village Voice to Substack.
Key scenes also turn to Christgau’s partnership with wife Carola Dibbell, whom Wishnow calls his “esthetic partner,” arguing the critic’s public work and private life are inseparable.
The film revisits Christgau’s blunt legacy—admired as a generous editor, attacked by artists including Lou Reed and Thurston Moore, and shadowed by some reviews Wishnow says crossed a line.
A wider release has yet to be announced, but the documentary casts Christgau’s still-active career as the possible endpoint of a paid professional music-critic vocation.