Updated
Updated · Fox News · Nov 17
Seattle Times Leaves Trans Athlete Claim Uncorrected Despite Studies Showing 12% Speed Edge
Updated
Updated · Fox News · Nov 17

Seattle Times Leaves Trans Athlete Claim Uncorrected Despite Studies Showing 12% Speed Edge

1 articles · Updated · Fox News · Nov 17

Summary

  • The Seattle Times has not issued a correction, clarification or editor’s note after criticism of its Nov. 8 claim that there is “no serious scientific evidence” transgender women hold athletic advantages over biological women.
  • Critics pointed to multiple studies, including a 2020 U.S. Air Force study showing transgender women remained 12% faster in a 1.5-mile run after two years of hormone therapy.
  • Other cited research included a 2025 paper finding retained advantages in strength, power, size and aerobic capacity, a 2020 review showing only a 5% muscle-mass loss after a year, and a 2021 review finding strength and lean mass still above female levels after three years.
  • The dispute centers on a Seattle Times article about Washington’s Initiative 638, which would bar biological males from girls’ K-12 sports and was backed overwhelmingly by voters.
  • Writers including Jason Rantz, Benjamin Ryan and Karen Crouse said they challenged the paper’s wording, but the newspaper did not respond publicly to requests for clarification.

Insights

What happens when the media presents complex, unresolved sports science as an absolute settled fact?