Study Says IRS Cut 115 Conservation Easement Appraisals by 97% on Average
Updated
Updated · Fox News · Nov 17
Study Says IRS Cut 115 Conservation Easement Appraisals by 97% on Average
1 articles · Updated · Fox News · Nov 17
Summary
115 conservation easement cases reviewed by Infinity Advisory Services showed the IRS cut taxpayers’ appraised values by about 97% on average, with 99% reductions or more common.
More than 130 IRS valuation reviews examined in the study pointed, its authors said, to a process aimed at predetermined outcomes rather than property-by-property analysis, effectively erasing deductions tied to donated development rights.
One Cleveland historic-building case cited by the study saw the same IRS reviewer shift an easement value from $18.1 million-$23.2 million to $400,000 after guidance from IRS counsel to exclude certain development rights.
A former IRS valuator told Fox News Digital officials pressured appraisers and dismissed taxpayer evidence, while Steve Moore said families face steep tax bills and possible bankruptcy despite the agency’s August pledge to revamp its approach.
The dispute comes as the IRS has also won recent court fights over inflated easement claims, including 11th Circuit rulings upholding $480,000 versus $23 million and $900,000 versus $8.9 million valuations, both with 40% penalties.