Updated

Updated · Kotaku · Aug 14

Kotaku Urges Nintendo to Give Mario a Gun After GTA Took 2002's Top 2 Sales Spots

Updated

Updated · Kotaku · Aug 14

Kotaku Urges Nintendo to Give Mario a Gun After GTA Took 2002's Top 2 Sales Spots

Q: How did the creators of a family-friendly plumber react when gritty gangsters stole their crown in 2002?

They did not publicly “turn Mario into a gangster.” Nintendo’s practical response was to stay the course with its family-friendly identity, even as Rockstar’s Grand Theft Auto: Vice City and Grand Theft Auto III took the top two U.S. sales spots in 2002 and Super Mario Sunshine finished 10th. The article’s “give Mario a gun” line was satire, not a record of Nintendo policy. It was meant to capture how sharply the market had shifted toward mature, crime-themed games on PlayStation. In reality, Nintendo continued to present Mario through bright, accessible games like Super Mario Sunshine, centered on cleaning up Isle Delfino, collecting Shine Sprites, and exploring hubs such as Delfino Plaza. That contrast is the real answer. Rockstar’s success showed that many U.S. players, including younger gamers who had grown up with Nintendo, were increasingly buying darker, more realistic games. But Nintendo did not visibly rebrand Mario to chase that audience in 2002. Instead, it preserved the character as the symbol of all-ages gaming while competitors benefited from the rising appeal of adult-oriented content. So when gritty gangsters “stole the crown,” the creators of the family-friendly plumber largely reacted by holding to Mario’s established role rather than imitating Grand Theft Auto.

1 articles · Updated · Kotaku · Aug 14

Grand Theft Auto: Vice City was the best-selling U.S. game of 2002, with Grand Theft Auto III at No. 2, prompting Kotaku to argue Nintendo should make Mario more violent and adult-oriented.
NPD data underscored the gap: Super Mario Sunshine finished only 10th despite being Mario's first 3D outing since 1996's Super Mario 64.
Kotaku framed the rankings as evidence that mainstream tastes had shifted from Nintendo's family-friendly franchises toward the gritty realism and mature themes associated with PlayStation hits like Grand Theft Auto.
The piece, part of Kotaku's 2002-themed Warp Week retrospective, used satire and a mock crime-story pitch to argue Nintendo had lost sales momentum as players aged into darker games.

Sources

Left100%

Kotaku6d ago

Kotaku Argues Nintendo Should Arm Mario After Grand Theft Auto Outsold Super Mario in 2002

Did a sudden craving for virtual crime permanently dethrone Nintendo's wholesome legacy in the early 2000s?

Was the 2002 gaming shift really about mature content, or did players just crave unprecedented open-world freedom?

How did the creators of a family-friendly plumber react when gritty gangsters stole their crown in 2002?

Sources

1 total

Left100%

Kotaku6d ago

Kotaku Argues Nintendo Should Arm Mario After Grand Theft Auto Outsold Super Mario in 2002

Kotaku Urges Nintendo to Give Mario a Gun After GTA Took 2002's Top 2 Sales Spots

Summary

Sources

Insights

Related Stories

Sources

Related Stories