Updated
Updated · CBS Sports · Sep 9
Western Michigan President Says Broncos Won 12-7 as NCAA Revises Replay Clock Rule
Updated
Updated · CBS Sports · Sep 9

Western Michigan President Says Broncos Won 12-7 as NCAA Revises Replay Clock Rule

3 articles · Updated · CBS Sports · Sep 9

Summary

  • Russ Kavalhuna said Western Michigan "won that football game," arguing the Broncos should be credited with a 12-7 victory before officials restored 1 second and Michigan scored on a 47-yard Hail Mary.
  • The NCAA has since told the MAC its rules provide no protocol to overturn a final result, even after changing replay guidance to use the embedded program-feed game clock—the standard under which Western Michigan says it wins.
  • The MAC filed formal appeals Tuesday with the FBS Oversight Committee and the College Football Playoff, seeking recognition of Western Michigan as the winner; CFP executive director Rich Clark said the request would need playoff management committee review.
  • Big Ten crews also expanded live referee-replay audio to every game they officiate, while Kavalhuna said Western Michigan kept a calm public posture even as it pressed the case privately over lost CFP and NIL opportunities.

Insights

Could a one-second clock error cost Western Michigan millions in playoff payouts despite the NCAA admitting the mistake?
Will the College Football Playoff committee defy the official record to reward a team robbed by a technical glitch?
If a referee clock error changes a game outcome, who compensates the players for lost NIL deals and postseason revenue?