Kathy Garver said the 2002 "Family Affair" remake failed because it lacked the chemistry, warmth and family bond that defined the 1966 original.
Gary Cole and Tim Curry were talented but miscast for viewers attached to Brian Keith and Sebastian Cabot, Garver said, arguing Curry's louder Mr. French became "the Tim Curry show" instead of a sitcom ensemble.
Garver said the original worked because its characters loved one another on screen, with Keith's tough-yet-tender uncle and Cabot's low-key affection giving the series emotional comfort and relatability.
Catchy Comedy will mark the show's 60th anniversary on Sept. 13 with an 8-episode marathon hosted by Garver, who said she would oppose any sequel.