Updated
Updated · Fox News · Sep 28
Clancy Sides Delay Motion to Probe 1 Holdout Juror Before Sept. 29 Hearing
Updated
Updated · Fox News · Sep 28

Clancy Sides Delay Motion to Probe 1 Holdout Juror Before Sept. 29 Hearing

3 articles · Updated · Fox News · Sep 28

Summary

  • Lindsay Clancy’s defense and Massachusetts prosecutors agreed to postpone Kevin Reddington’s motion to investigate holdout juror Michael Desronvil, pending Judge William Sullivan’s approval.
  • Edward Paltzik, Desronvil’s lawyer, said he lacks access to impounded material needed to prepare a response, making the juror-focused motion unlikely to be heard Tuesday.
  • A 9 a.m. status conference is still expected in Plymouth — Clancy’s first court appearance since the Sept. 4 mistrial — and prosecutors are due to update the court on next steps.
  • The delayed motion had sought an inquiry into Desronvil, the lone juror who held Clancy guilty of murder, while 11 others favored a verdict of not guilty by reason of mental disease or defect.
  • Clancy faces three first-degree murder charges in the January 2023 strangling deaths of her children, and the court is also weighing a double-jeopardy bid to dismiss the case instead of retrying it.

Insights

Why are prosecutors still undecided after an 11-1 mistrial, and what could push the Clancy case toward dismissal, acquittal, or another trial?
Could the delayed juror inquiry determine whether Lindsay Clancy faces a retrial, or does the real fight center on double jeopardy?
When a lone holdout juror is challenged after a deadlocked verdict, where does legitimate scrutiny end and jury independence begin?