Updated
Updated · The New York Times · Nov 6
Trump Appeals Dismissal of $10 Billion Wall Street Journal Libel Suit
Updated
Updated · The New York Times · Nov 6

Trump Appeals Dismissal of $10 Billion Wall Street Journal Libel Suit

3 articles · Updated · The New York Times · Nov 6

Summary

  • Thursday’s filing sends Trump’s challenge to the 11th Circuit after a Florida federal judge dismissed his $10 billion defamation case against The Wall Street Journal with prejudice in October.
  • Judge Darrin Gayles ruled Trump failed to show “actual malice,” the standard requiring public figures to prove a publisher knew a claim was false or recklessly disregarded the truth.
  • The suit targeted a 2025 Journal article reporting that Trump appeared to have written a lewd birthday message to Jeffrey Epstein more than 20 years earlier; Trump denies writing it or drawing the accompanying image.
  • Trump first sued a day after the article appeared, lost that case in April, refiled in May, and was dismissed again in October, leaving appeal as his remaining path in the case.

Insights

Could this massive defamation appeal redefine the boundaries of press freedom when reporting on high-profile public figures?
Will the appellate court uphold the strict actual malice standard protecting the newspaper against the defamation claim?