Updated
Updated · The Washington Post · Nov 16
Judge Dismisses Max Miller Defamation Suit, Rules Hot-Water Abuse Claim Substantially True
Updated
Updated · The Washington Post · Nov 16

Judge Dismisses Max Miller Defamation Suit, Rules Hot-Water Abuse Claim Substantially True

3 articles · Updated · The Washington Post · Nov 16

Summary

  • Cuyahoga County Judge Joy Kennedy dismissed Rep. Max Miller’s defamation suit with prejudice, barring him from refiling and ordering him to pay court costs plus part of Emily Moreno’s legal fees.
  • An audio recording and existing court and police records undercut Miller’s claim that Moreno lied, with Kennedy finding the allegation that he doused her with hot water was “substantially true.”
  • Kennedy also found no credible evidence that Moreno leaked the allegations to the Daily Mail, rejecting a central part of Miller’s May lawsuit.
  • Miller, 38, denied Moreno’s broader abuse claims, but the case unfolded alongside a House Ethics Committee probe and Republican calls for his resignation.
  • The ruling lands after Miller lost his reelection bid this month by about 10 points in Ohio’s 7th District, a seat Donald Trump had carried by 11 points in 2024.

Insights

What happens when a public figure's attempt to silence an ex-spouse backfires with a court ruling the abuse claims substantially true?
Could the application of the Uniform Public Expression Protection Act in this divorce redefine how defamation cases are handled?