Experts Warn Trump Immigration Deal Could Cost Taxpayers $50 Billion as He Floats Legal Status
Updated
Updated · Fox News · Nov 16
Experts Warn Trump Immigration Deal Could Cost Taxpayers $50 Billion as He Floats Legal Status
3 articles · Updated · Fox News · Nov 16
Summary
Trump’s suggestion in a post-midterm “60 Minutes” interview that he could work with Democrats on legal status for some undocumented immigrants drew warnings from immigration analysts over rule-of-law, assimilation and fiscal risks.
Steven Camarota of the Center for Immigration Studies said legalization would reward lawbreaking, undercut immigrants who followed legal channels and fail to restore enforcement credibility.
On costs, Camarota estimated households headed by undocumented immigrants already receive about $50 billion a year in benefits and argued legalization would expand eligibility without producing a major tax windfall.
Laura Collins of the George W. Bush Presidential Center countered that broken immigration laws drive the problem, saying legalization with fines, background checks and work authorization could improve assimilation and raise revenues; she cited a 2013 CBO estimate of $158 billion in deficit reduction over 10 years.
Trump later said “There won’t be amnesty,” while CIS’s Mark Krikorian argued any deal is unlikely because Democrats would offer little in exchange, even on DACA recipients.