Judge Perry Challenges DOJ Privilege Claims in Broadview Six Probe, Orders 4 Witnesses to Submit Testimony
Updated
Updated · Chicago Tribune · Nov 16
Judge Perry Challenges DOJ Privilege Claims in Broadview Six Probe, Orders 4 Witnesses to Submit Testimony
3 articles · Updated · Chicago Tribune · Nov 16
Summary
Judge April Perry signaled Monday she is unlikely to accept the Justice Department’s privilege arguments, saying existing case law generally does not shield factual testimony in her misconduct inquiry.
Four witnesses — U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros and prosecutors William Hogan, Matthew Skiba and Andres Almendarez — must email written versions of potentially privileged testimony by Friday, with government responses due Nov. 25.
Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward argued putting witnesses on the stand creates an “intolerably high risk” of exposing privileged material and questioned whether Perry should decide those disputes herself.
Lawyers for Hogan, Skiba and Almendarez said their clients do not plan to assert personal privileges, while Boutros skipped Monday’s hearing and has no private lawyer on the case.
The clash sets up a Dec. 2 hearing in the Broadview Six case, dismissed in May after alleged grand jury misconduct in a 2025 protest prosecution tied to the Trump administration’s deportation push.
Why is a top DOJ antitrust official intervening in a Chicago protest case to shield line prosecutors from testifying about misconduct?
The Collapse of the Broadview Six Prosecution: 2026 Chicago Hearing Unveils DOJ Misconduct and Sparks National Grand Jury Reform
Overview
The Broadview Six case began with protests against a Trump administration immigration crackdown in September 2025, leading to a controversial federal indictment after prosecutors struggled to secure charges through three grand juries. U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros personally intervened, removing skeptical jurors, and the case collapsed in May 2026 when a judge uncovered prosecutorial misconduct, including improper juror removals and misleading court statements. This triggered resignations, an internal audit of past cases, and a December 2026 evidentiary hearing where prosecutors must testify under oath. The scandal exposed deep rifts between local prosecutors and DOJ leadership, forcing unprecedented judicial oversight and systemic reforms.