Updated
Updated · Chicago Tribune · Nov 16
Judge Perry Challenges DOJ Privilege Claims in Broadview Six Probe, Orders 4 Witnesses to Submit Testimony
Updated
Updated · Chicago Tribune · Nov 16

Judge Perry Challenges DOJ Privilege Claims in Broadview Six Probe, Orders 4 Witnesses to Submit Testimony

3 articles · Updated · Chicago Tribune · Nov 16

Summary

  • Judge April Perry signaled Monday she is unlikely to accept the Justice Department’s privilege arguments, saying existing case law generally does not shield factual testimony in her misconduct inquiry.
  • Four witnesses — U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros and prosecutors William Hogan, Matthew Skiba and Andres Almendarez — must email written versions of potentially privileged testimony by Friday, with government responses due Nov. 25.
  • Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward argued putting witnesses on the stand creates an “intolerably high risk” of exposing privileged material and questioned whether Perry should decide those disputes herself.
  • Lawyers for Hogan, Skiba and Almendarez said their clients do not plan to assert personal privileges, while Boutros skipped Monday’s hearing and has no private lawyer on the case.
  • The clash sets up a Dec. 2 hearing in the Broadview Six case, dismissed in May after alleged grand jury misconduct in a 2025 protest prosecution tied to the Trump administration’s deportation push.

Insights

Why is a top DOJ antitrust official intervening in a Chicago protest case to shield line prosecutors from testifying about misconduct?

The Collapse of the Broadview Six Prosecution: 2026 Chicago Hearing Unveils DOJ Misconduct and Sparks National Grand Jury Reform

Overview

The Broadview Six case began with protests against a Trump administration immigration crackdown in September 2025, leading to a controversial federal indictment after prosecutors struggled to secure charges through three grand juries. U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros personally intervened, removing skeptical jurors, and the case collapsed in May 2026 when a judge uncovered prosecutorial misconduct, including improper juror removals and misleading court statements. This triggered resignations, an internal audit of past cases, and a December 2026 evidentiary hearing where prosecutors must testify under oath. The scandal exposed deep rifts between local prosecutors and DOJ leadership, forcing unprecedented judicial oversight and systemic reforms.

...