Updated
Updated · Tom's Guide · Sep 23
iPhone 18 Pro Max Beats iPhone 17 Pro Max in 6 of 7 Rounds Despite $1,299 Price
Updated
Updated · Tom's Guide · Sep 23

iPhone 18 Pro Max Beats iPhone 17 Pro Max in 6 of 7 Rounds Despite $1,299 Price

3 articles · Updated · Tom's Guide · Sep 23

Summary

  • A seven-category comparison gave the iPhone 18 Pro Max six wins, with the iPhone 17 Pro Max taking value on its lower $1,199 starting price and design ending in a tie.
  • The new model pulled ahead on hardware: an A20 Pro chip delivered roughly 22% faster single-core and 28% faster multi-core performance, while 3DMark graphics rose 45% to 67.9 fps.
  • Camera upgrades drove much of the gap, with a 48MP main sensor adding variable aperture and native Pro Controls; the review found better low-light shots, cleaner 40x zoom and improved selfies.
  • Display and battery gains were smaller but still favored the 18 Pro Max, which hit 2,326 nits versus 1,899 nits and lasted 18 hours 27 minutes versus 17:54 in a 5G web test.
  • Charging was the clearest everyday upgrade: 60W support pushed the 18 Pro Max to 44% in 15 minutes and 77% in 30, though the review said current 17 Pro Max owners may struggle to justify the extra $100.

Insights

With a fragile mechanical camera and a higher price, is Apple's iPhone 18 Pro Max actually a downgrade in disguise?
Will the hidden repair risks of the groundbreaking variable-aperture camera turn this new Apple flagship into a costly nightmare?